OEM Versus Aftermarket and Used

Restoring your car to its pre-collision condition


As stated in your policy, your insurance company will  employ a collision and repair auto body shop to repair, rebuild, or replace any damaged parts with other parts “of like kind and quality.” This means that if there is damage to the front fender of your five-year-old vehicle, your insurer can replace the damaged fender with a used one “of like kind and quality” as the original. The justification is that your five-year-old car is not in new condition and the aftermarket fender is good enough and suitable for the repair or is it? Some clients maintain their vehicles in immaculate condition for 10+ years. Is an aftermarket bumper good enough for them?

Note here that if your vehicle is less than a year old, your insurance company will likely be ok with Original Equipment Manufacturer (OEM) parts to replace any damaged parts. Some insurance companies up to 2 years but beyond that who knows? Each company has its own limits. As an insured client, you should inquire with your insurer before an accident to make sure what you get is what you want.

But you know, there are professional auto body shops and collision centres who always try to use OEM in every repair and never settle for used parts in their restorations, no matter how old your car is. These collision and autobody shops rely on consumers understanding the difference between a repair and a restoration of a car to its condition prior to an accident. The use of OEM parts maintains manufacturer warranties and maintains the resale value of your car as well. Would you not want to keep both in good standing? Does it not make good sense to do so?

My advice, deal with collision and autobody shops that push to use OEM parts. It is the better solution! These shops will only use aftermarket or used parts if the owner agrees to it in the end. You, the owner of the car, make the decision. That’s how it should be!


Mike Tikl
Proud owner of Mitek Fine Autobody & Paint

Serving Kitchener, Waterloo. Cambridge, Guelph

Your Fine Car Deserves our Fine Care

Recent Posts

Maintaining Your Luxury Car’s Value After a Collision

Maintaining Your Luxury Car’s Value After a Collision No matter where you live or what kind of car you drive, being involved in a collision is a terrible experience. For owners of luxury cars, it can be extra harrowing. For those who have a passion and appreciation...

What to Do After an Accident

What to Do After an Accident If you’ve never been involved in an accident, you can’t really appreciate what a stressful and unpleasant experience it can be. Your mind and body go through a rapid series of responses that can include everything from shock and dismay to...

Debunking Common Collision Repair Myths

Debunking Common Collision Repair Myths In a world where information—and misinformation—are so readily available, it’s getting harder than ever to separate facts from falsehoods. When you’ve been involved in an accident, the confusion surrounding these so-called...

The Ongoing Evolution of Collision Repair Technologies

The Ongoing Evolution of Collision Repair Technologies Until the invasion of modern technology, the auto body repair process had stayed pretty much the same for many years. Then seemingly all at once, the onset of computerization brought with it a whole slew of...